If the story concerns a Main Character who Changes, he will come to believe he is the cause of his own problems (that’s why he eventually changes). If he grows out of an old attitude or approach (e.g. loses the chip on his shoulder), then he is a Stop character. If he grows into a new way of being (e.g. fills a hole in his heart), then he is a Start character.
If the story concerns a Main Character who Remains Steadfast, something in the world around him will appear to be the cause of his troubles. If he tries to hold out long enough for something to stop bothering him, then he is a Stop character. If he tries to hold out long enough for something to begin, then he is a Start character. If you want the emphasis in your story to be on the source of the troubles which has to stop, choose “Stop.” If you want to emphasize that the remedy to the problems has to begin, choose “Start.”
Whether a Main Character eventually changes his nature or remains steadfast, he will still grow over the course of the story. This growth has a direction. Either he will grow into something (Start) or grow out of something (Stop).
As an example we can look to Scrooge from Charles Dickens’ A Christmas Carol. Does Scrooge need to change because he is excessively miserly (Stop), or because he lacks generosity (Start)? In the Dickens’ story it is clear that Scrooge’s problems stem from his passive lack of compassion, not from his active greed. It is not that he is on the attack, but that he does not actively seek to help others. So, according to the way Charles Dickens told the story, Scrooge needs to Start being generous, rather than Stop being miserly.
A Change Main Character grows by adding a characteristic he lacks (Start) or by dropping a characteristic he already has (Stop). Either way, his make up is changed in nature.
A Steadfast Main Character’s make up, in contrast, does not change in nature. He grows in his resolve to remain unchanged. He can grow by holding out against something that is increasingly bad while waiting for it to Stop. He can also grow by holding out for something in his environment to Start. Either way, the change appears somewhere in his environment instead of in him.
Stop: Change Main Character
- Frank Galvin, The Verdict - he must stop disbelieving as a prerequisite to gaining faith.
- Luke Skywalker, Star Wars - he must stop testing his skills as a prerequisite to gaining trust in himself (and the force).
Stop: Steadfast Main Character
- David Moscow, Big - he must wait until his “big” condition stops.
- Dr. Richard Kimble, The Fugitive - he must hold out until his position as a fugitive stops.
Start: Change Main Character
- Scrooge, A Christmas Carol - he must start being compassionate.
Start: Steadfast Main Character
- Ray Kinsella, Field of Dreams - he must wait for something in order to start enjoying the ballpark he built.
- George, Who’s Afraid of Virgina Woolf? - he must wait for Martha to be able to tell the difference between truth and illusion.